The best mince pies 2026 – tried and tasted
We taste-tested supermarket and big-brand mince pies to find the best to buy this year – and the ones we’d leave on the shelf.
We taste-tested supermarket and big-brand mince pies to find the best to buy this year – and the ones we’d leave on the shelf.
It wouldn’t be Christmas without a mince pie. They are great warm with brandy butter or cold with a cuppa, and make the perfect gift for Santa.
The best are delicious, made of a buttery pastry filled with a sweet mincemeat of fruit and spices, while the worst leave you with a mouth full of dry tasteless pastry, or nauseous from their sickly sweet jam-style filling.
You can choose from classic mince pies, luxury varieties boasting extra butter and alcohol or, more recently, ones filled with a variety of surprising flavour combinations.
Read our guide to the energy price cap – and how to keep your bills low this winter.
The choice can be bewildering at what is already a busy time.
So, to help you decide which mince pies to buy in 2026, our tasting panel sampled 27 different mince pies on offer in the supermarkets along with other big brands, to decide which are the true Christmas crackers, and which to avoid.
Taking taste, quality and value for money into account, these were our overall winners for 2026.
Our tasting was done in one sitting, with all the pies cold and without any cream or other accompaniment.
Pies were quartered to ensure that all testers had the right balance of filling and pastry.
Heating does improve mince pies, but for consistency of testing we tested them straight out of the box.
Our testers were looking for a good amount of filling in each pie. Mincemeat should be mostly dried fruit, flavoured with spices and brandy, so our testers wanted to be able to taste this in their pie and also feel a texture of fruit in the mouth.
The balance between pastry and filling is important: too much pastry and you won’t taste the mincemeat, plus you could end up with a mouthful of tasteless powder that is difficult to swallow.
Some of the pies tested had all-butter pastry, some were “butter-enriched” and some contained no butter at all. But whatever the blend, we were searching for a pastry with taste which was properly cooked.
RRP: £2.50 (pack of six)
Simple looking mince pies but they had a really nice buttery smell.
The pies were well-filled and the filling had texture. The mincemeat wasn’t too sweet and the taste of fruit really came through. Our team all loved the buttery pastry and agreed that these tasted more of fruit than spice and there was no hint of alcohol.
These are almost twice as expensive as others in this category. But the fruitiness makes them a perfect family mince pie. They were second last year in this category, and won by a whisker this year.
RRP: £1.39 (pack of six)
Everyone liked the look of these pies, which had a pretty design and the pastry had colour.
The mincemeat was fruity, not too sweet and had just the right hint of spice. Despite the promise that the mincemeat was infused with cognac, port and cider there was no taste of alcohol.
The pastry was buttery and well cooked – there was a bit too much for some tasters, but it didn’t ruin the pie.
The team agreed it was a great budget mince pie, but despite the difference in price it was just pipped to the post in this category by the M&S offering. But if you are on a budget, then you really can’t go wrong with this one.
RRP: £1.50 (pack of six)
This is not a bad mince pie at all and you’ll regularly find it reduced in store. The pies all have nice designs and they have a smell of mincemeat.
The team thought the pastry was good and short and not claggy. It didn’t have a rich buttery taste but it did work well with the mincemeat.
Tasters thought there was a good amount of filling which had texture and some spice also came through. A good bronze medallist in this category.
RRP: £3 (pack of six)
These pies didn’t have any discernable smell when the packet was opened. Our testers felt that the filling was sweet without any texture, no spice either.
However, the pastry was nice and buttery. Good for those with a sweet tooth.
RRP: £3 (pack of six)
This pie smelt of spice even before tasting. Our team felt the filling was too sweet, although a citrus taste came through.
The pastry was good though and everyone agreed this was the best bit of the pie.
RRP: £1.19 (pack of six)
There’s a lot of pastry in this pie and our tasters commented on how soft the pastry was. The pies overall were very sweet and bland, the filling was jammy with a bit of spice aftertaste.
They may benefit from heating.
RRP: £1.25 (pack of six)
These had a home-made look, with some appearing a bit lopsided. They held together well, but the pastry was very thick.
“It’s like jam!” one of our team commented. There was no texture to the filling, which was very sweet and with no fruit.
Iceland recommends serving them warm, which we didn’t do in our taste test, but it could only improve them.
RRP: £1.25 (pack of six)
These didn’t have any smell when the packet was opened and had a really mean filling.
The filling was jammy and sweet with no spice to be tasted. “It’s just sugar” one of our tasters said.
These were the lowest scoring in the category.
“There is nothing better than warm mince pies at Christmas,” says expert Sam Milner.
“If you are reheating mince pies in the air fryer, then follow the golden rule of reheating at 160°C/320°F – as you don’t want to be cooking the mince pies again or drying them out.
“Then air fry them for about 4 minutes. You can add an extra minute if your air fryer is a little slow.”
Sam Milner is the author of a range of best-selling air fryer cookbooks.
RRP: £10.95 (pack of six)
You really did read it right. These six pies cost £10.95 (that's approx £1.82p each). That’s a lot of money for a pie to eat at home.
Our testers were very wary. How could a home-eating mince pie justify the price? Upon opening the packet there was an instant smell of booze, spice and fruit.
The pie had a thin crispy shortcrust pastry. The filling wasn’t too sweet, but boozy, spicy and with loads of fruit. The most perfect mass-produced mince pie any of the team had ever eaten.
Yes, these pies are expensive but they are better and cheaper than most coffee shop offerings. The tasted pie deserved its rare score from the team and I will be buying a packet as a treat this Christmas.
RRP: £4 (pack of six)
Last year these mince pies didn’t impress us at all with their jammy filling. But this year they scooped second place.
The overly sweet filling has been replaced with a lovely mincemeat full of fruit, spice and with a taste of cognac too.
Once again everyone liked the pastry, which had a darker buttery taste and a nice crunch.
RRP: £5 (pack of four)
These offerings sold through Waitrose are more expensive than most, £5 buys you just four mince pies.
They also contain a more unusual spiced pineapple mincemeat with rum – but then what else would you expect from the chef Yotam Ottolenghi?
What did our team think? “You can smell the star anise,” was the comment. And they tasted of it too, so if you don’t like aniseed you won’t like these.
However the pie had a lovely soft buttery pastry and the mincemeat was lovely, not too sweet and the taste of pineapple actually came through. They aren’t traditional but as long as you like aniseed they are a very nice pie.
RRP: £3 (pack of six)
These really weren’t bad at all and so much cheaper than the top three, especially if you are watching your pennies.
The pies had a lovely spicy smell and the mincemeat contained loads of fruit. The pastry had taste – it wasn’t as rich as others, but it wasn’t at all claggy.
A really good mince pie for the money.
RRP: £3 (pack of six)
These Tesco pies had nice buttery pastry, which wasn’t claggy at all. Our team had quite a conversation about the filling as it wasn’t spicy or boozy, but it was fruity.
“This is a great family mince pie,” was the comment. And that’s what the verdict was in the end. If you want a family-friendly fruity mince pie, that isn’t too sweet, spicy or boozy, then this is a great choice.
RRP: £3.50 (pack of six)
These pies smelled of jam. The pastry was more biscuit than shortcrust, but our team liked it. The filling was a bit nondescript, more fruit and jam than mincemeat.
However they weren’t unpleasant and the taste of fruit did come through.
RRP: £3.50 (packet of six)
The packaging on these pies looked expensive. But unfortunately the pies didn’t live up to its promise. There wasn’t a lot of taste to these.
Our team found them very jammy, no texture, there was some spice but no alcohol as promised. The pastry was a bit claggy too.
Disappointing, especially when the M&S classic mince pies were so good.
RRP: £2.79 (Pack of six)
These looked almost homemade with the filling bubbling over the edges in places.
There was a bit of a spice smell, but there was a lot of pastry and not much filling to balance it out. Our team weren’t keen because even the filling that was there was too sweet and jammy, rather than a good mincemeat. Not a good balance unfortunately.
RRP: £3.15 (pack of one)
We wanted to compare a coffee shop chain pie with the home eating ones to see how it fared. Like previous years this one didn’t do as well as you would hope, considering the cost (it’s more expensive than the Fortnum and Mason pies).
The pie is more of a tart than a pie and bigger than others tested. It had a caramel taste, with cinnamon coming through too.
But our team found it had too much pastry and was too sweet overall to score high. Everyone did agree that it would be better with a coffee to accompany it.
Our team tried two of the vegan mince pies on offer for Christmas 2026.
Favourite was the Tesco Plant Chef Mince Pies (£2 for six). The pastry was crumbly but somehow claggy at the same time. The mincemeat filling was okay, fruity but with no spice or alcohol.
The Greggs Merry Little Moments Mince Pies (RRP: £2.60 for six) were popular in 2024, but this year the ones tasted weren’t as nice. Testers could detect the fruit, but no spice came through. The pastry tasted more like a wholemeal pastry and our team preferred the Tesco offering.
Once again there were plenty of contenders vying for the crown of most unusual mince pie. The best still left our testers with mixed emotions – are they really any better than a good traditional mince pie?
While the worst? Well, it was bottom last year and it’s kept its placing again this year.
RRP: £2.99 (box of six)
Even though these boasted Jamaican rum on the packaging, our tasters got cinnamon from these tarts when they tasted them.
They don’t have a true mincemeat texture and a few of our team members weren’t really sure what they really tasted like, but they weren’t unpleasant and they got the thumbs up from some tasters.
RRP: £3 (pack of four)
These pies were a bit unusual. It’s not often you see a cream topping on a mince pie. But the brandy buttercream turned out to be very sugary and didn’t taste much of brandy. The taste of it swamped the rest of the pie.
If you don’t like mince pies, but do like a very sweet carrot cake, then you may like these.
RRP: £2.99 (pack of six)
Another mince pie for people who don’t like mince pies. These almost tarts have a very strong taste of cinnamon. Our team felt they tasted more like a coffee biscuit than anything approaching a festive mince pie.
If you adore a Biscoff then you may well enjoy these too.
RRP: £4 (pack of four)
You can definitely taste the pistachios in this pie, but our tasters found them too sweet, without any hint of the sour cherries.
One of our team loves pistachios but even her comment was, “I’d rather eat a cookie.”
RRP: £3.50 (pack of four)
These were dry and claggy at the same time. They didn’t have a particularly Bakewell taste either.
Our tasters said the problem was they were neither a mince pie, nor a Bakewell tart.
RRP: £2.49 (pack of four)
These festive tarts are said to be finished with a brownie crumb, caramel sauce and chocolate.
“It’s like a dry chocolate biscuit, isn’t it?” one of our testers remarked. And they had a point. These were the least popular of the flavoured pies, with no mincemeat and not a lot of taste.
The supermarkets are stocking a good choice of gluten-free mince pies for 2026.
We’ve had good reports on the Waitrose Free From Milk & Gluten Free Mince Pies (RRP: £3.10 for four) and M&S Collection Made Without Wheat Gluten Free 4 All Butter Mince Pies (RRP: £3.50 for four).
A big thanks to our hosts at Goytre Hall for hosting our tasting session.
Phillipa Cherryson is senior digital editor for Saga Magazine. Phillipa has been a journalist for 30 years, writing for national newspapers, magazines and reporting onscreen for ITV. In her spare time she loves the outdoors and is an Ordnance Survey Champion and trainee mountain leader.
View author page
Your chance to win cruise for two to Cádiz, Casablanca and the Canary Islands, worth more than £9,600.
Whether you're looking for straightforward insurance or cover that's packed with extras, our home insurance has plenty of options for people over 50.
From a smart bird feeder and a talking chess board to fitness kit and a pocket photo printer.
Our choice of the 6 best cookbooks to buy for Christmas, filled with delicious inspiration.
If you want your home to look festive rather than frightful, we have the best advice on how to dodge decorative disasters.
From “bauble-bearers“ to festive “wambling” our lexicographer has a host of words that capture the spirit of Christmas.
Our money expert looks at your choices, from giving money to setting up a pension.
Crisp and golden, a Yorkshire pudding is essential for a great Sunday roast. Try our super-easy recipe.
We review the best supermarket Christmas puddings available in 2025, with selections from the likes of Asda, Morrisons, Tesco and M&S.
Are Christmas cards going out of fashion? Not according to our survey.